Re: Do u think shia's are united???

Admin · by Admin on Thu May 01, 2008 8:26 pm

Noway! Because they are Kafir in our eyes, but one way we can united which is Humanate thats all

Fida wal muqawamah · by Fida wal muqawamah on Mon Jul 07, 2008 8:51 am

we should b united.. no doubt but the question was that ARE WE UNITED??? my answer to that is NO!!! we are not united... like sis zainab wrote ppl excuse namaz over majalises... there are ppl who instead saying salam say YA ALI MADAD!!!! wat on earth is this... give one example when Prophet (PBUH&HP) or any of our imams or bibi fatima(sa) said ya ali madad instead of salam... have we more love for Imam Ali(as) than them.. Fatima(sa) gave her entire life defending islam and WILAYAT as well as other imams... Fatima (sa) ws the first defender of Wilayat... has she ever lapsed her prayers... not even night prayers.. then who we r to do changings in the shariat... Prophet(PBUH&HP) in his last sermon delivered words that became the constitution of islamic poliical system in favor of Ali(as) has he(pbuh) ever said ya ali madad instead of salam... plus he was the first one to call ali(as) in khyber in need of help(as recited by shia zakirin) he never lapsed his prayers instead prophet used to pray very excessively...
The question regarding marjayat... its true that at certain points there r different fatwas but on the whole all the fatwas remain same.. read tuzi ul masail of different marjas like sistani, khomeni and gulpaygani.. one observe a mark rresemblance in the fatwas.. but someone answered this quury quite nicely.. three persons asked imam wat to do against the oppression of the ruler imam wrote"jim(an urdu alphabet that comes after "say")... one of them took the alphabet is for JIHAD.. the other tok it for JUNOON(taqayea).. the other took it for JILA WATNI... islam ki roo se three of them took steps which were under the teachings of islam but were different... humari aqalen imam k jumlat ko darq karne k liye kafi nai... for it we need specialists and those are marjas...

Syeda · by Syeda on Tue Jul 15, 2008 11:32 pm

salam,
Fida excellent reply!!! Very Happy

Syeda · by Syeda on Tue Jul 15, 2008 11:36 pm

Fida wal muqawamah wrote:like sis zainab wrote ppl excuse namaz over majalises... there are ppl who instead saying salam say YA ALI MADAD!!!! wat on earth is this... give one example when Prophet (PBUH&HP) or any of our imams or bibi fatima(sa) said ya ali madad instead of salam... have we more love for Imam Ali(as) than them.....

Wanted to say the same thing!!! Surprised

Fida wal muqawamah · by Fida wal muqawamah on Wed Jul 16, 2008 9:56 am

Walaykum salam syeda,
Thanks for the appreciation Very Happy

!